Housing Market Crash

Fannie Mae's latest prediction reveals a staggering decline in home sales, projected to reach a 29-year low in 2024. This forecast comes despite falling mortgage rates and a notable increase in housing inventory across many regions in the United States.

Current Trends in Home Sales

Despite the favorable conditions of decreasing mortgage rates and increased housing inventory, the market has shown a surprising trend. Existing home sales are projected to remain stagnant, not showing any significant uptick through the remainder of the year. This is a stark contrast to what one might expect given the economic conditions.

Fannie Mae's forecast suggests that we are experiencing the slowest pace of home sales since 1995. This is quite astonishing considering the substantial population growth and the increase in housing stock since then.

The forecast for this year is that we will see around 4.62 million existing home sales. This would be a slight decrease from last year's already low figure of just over 4 million sales. To put this in perspective, this is about 24% lower than the home sales figures from 2019 and 2018.

Historical Context of Home Sales

To understand the gravity of the current home sales forecast, it's essential to look at historical trends. Historically, the average number of home sales going back to 1989 is around 5 million per year. The forecast for this year, however, is about 1 million fewer sales than this long-term average.

In 1995, the U.S. had just over 3.8 million home sales. Fast forward to 2024, despite having tens of millions more people and a significantly higher number of houses, we are projected to have a similar number of home sales.

The U.S. Census Bureau reports that there are approximately 50 million more people living in the country now compared to the year 2000. Despite this population increase, the home sales figures are not reflecting this growth.

Forecasted Home Sales for 2024

Fannie Mae's forecast suggests that 2024 will see about 4.105 million home sales. While this is a slight upward revision from previous forecasts, it still represents a significant decline from historical averages. This figure would be the highest in three years but still about 500,000 fewer sales compared to the longer-term average.

For those curious about how this forecast compares to others, Zillow's recent forecast aligns closely with Fannie Mae's, predicting around 4.1 million sales for this year. My own forecast, announced a few months ago, predicts just under 4 million sales, around 3.97 million.

Comparison with Previous Years

  • 2019: Home sales were around 5 million.
  • 2022: Home sales dropped to approximately 4.1 million.
  • 2023: Forecasted to be just under 4.1 million.
  • 2024: Forecasted to be around 4.105 million.

These figures highlight a significant downward trend in home sales over the past few years, with 2024 expected to be among the lowest in nearly three decades.

Impact of Low Sales on Inventory Levels

When home sales are low, it can have a direct impact on inventory levels. A low level of transactions can put upward pressure on inventory levels, as fewer homes are being sold and thus remain on the market longer.

However, new listings play a crucial role here. A decrease in new listings can counterbalance the upward pressure on inventory caused by low sales. This creates a complex interplay between supply and demand.

The Bathtub Analogy for Supply and Demand

Imagine the housing market as a bathtub. The water level represents the number of homes for sale, or inventory levels. The water flowing into the bathtub symbolizes new listings, while the water draining out represents home sales.

  • If home sales decrease (the drain gets plugged), the water level (inventory) rises.
  • If new listings increase (more water flows in), the water level also rises.
  • If both new listings and sales are low, the water level remains relatively stable.

This analogy helps illustrate the balance between supply and demand in the housing market. It's a delicate equilibrium that can be tipped by changes in either new listings or home sales.

Understanding this dynamic is crucial for predicting future trends in the housing market. If new supply increases significantly while sales remain low, we could see a substantial rise in inventory levels. Conversely, if new listings decrease, it could help stabilize or even reduce inventory levels despite low sales.

Economic Implications of Low Home Sales

The forecasted decline in home sales has far-reaching implications for the U.S. economy. Real estate transactions contribute significantly to GDP, and a reduction in home sales can impact various sectors, from construction to consumer spending.

Impact on GDP

Home sales drive a considerable portion of the economy. When people buy homes, they often spend on renovations, furnishings, and other home-related products. This spending benefits numerous industries and supports jobs, from construction workers to retail employees. A decline in home sales can lead to reduced economic activity in these sectors, potentially slowing overall economic growth.

Employment in Real Estate and Related Sectors

The real estate sector directly employs millions of people, including real estate agents, brokers, and construction workers. Additionally, many other jobs are indirectly supported by home sales, such as home inspectors, appraisers, and mortgage lenders. A sustained drop in home sales could lead to job losses and reduced income for those employed in these fields, further impacting the economy.

Consumer Confidence and Spending

Homeownership is often associated with financial stability and confidence. When home sales are low, it can signal economic uncertainty, leading to reduced consumer confidence and spending. This reduction in spending can affect various industries, from retail to hospitality, compounding the economic impact of low home sales.

Predictions for 2025 Home Sales

Looking ahead, Fannie Mae's forecast for 2025 shows a modest recovery in home sales, with an estimated 4.505 million sales. While this is an improvement from 2024's forecast, it still falls short of historical averages.

Factors Influencing 2025 Predictions

Several factors contribute to the 2025 home sales forecast:

  • Economic Recovery: If the economy recovers from any downturns experienced in 2023 and 2024, consumer confidence and spending could increase, leading to higher home sales.
  • Mortgage Rates: Predicted declines in mortgage rates could make homeownership more affordable, encouraging more buyers to enter the market.
  • Housing Supply: An increase in housing starts and new home construction could provide more options for buyers, supporting higher sales numbers.

Comparison with Historical Averages

Even with the predicted increase, 2025 home sales are expected to be around 500,000 fewer than the long-term average of just over 5 million. This indicates that while the market may be recovering, it is not expected to return to pre-pandemic levels in the near term.

Pending Home Sales and Mortgage Applications

Pending home sales and mortgage applications are key indicators of future home sales. Recent data shows softness in these areas, suggesting limited home purchase demand at current affordability levels.

Pending Home Sales

The Pending Home Sales Index, which measures contracts signed between buyers and sellers, showed a small increase of 6% in August. However, this comes after a significant drop to the lowest levels since 2001 in July. The slight increase still leaves the index at the second-lowest reading on record, indicating continued challenges in the market.

Mortgage Applications

Mortgage applications for home purchases have remained flat throughout the year, reflecting ongoing affordability issues. The Mortgage Bankers Association's Purchase Index shows a significant decline compared to previous years, with current levels about half of what they were in early 2021.

Implications for Future Home Sales

The combination of low pending home sales and mortgage applications suggests that the housing market will continue to face challenges in the coming months. Limited demand at current affordability levels means that home sales are unlikely to see significant growth in the near future.

Analysis of Recent Housing Inventory Trends

Housing inventory levels have seen notable changes recently, with a significant increase in the number of homes for sale. However, this has not translated into higher sales, indicating a complex interplay between supply, demand, and affordability.

Regional Variations

The increase in housing inventory has been more pronounced in certain regions, particularly the Sun Belt and Mountain West. These areas have experienced strong home price growth and robust new home construction, contributing to higher inventory levels.

Impact of New Home Construction

New home construction has added to the overall housing supply, particularly in regions with high demand. This increased competition from new homes can impact the resale market, as buyers have more options to choose from.

Affordability Challenges

Despite the increase in inventory, affordability remains a significant issue. High home prices and mortgage rates continue to limit the number of potential buyers, leading to lower sales despite the higher number of homes available.

Future of Home Construction and Housing Starts

Fannie Mae's forecast for housing starts indicates a modest increase in new home construction in 2024, followed by a slight decrease in 2025. This suggests a cautious approach by home builders in response to current market conditions.

2024 Housing Starts

Housing starts for single-family homes are expected to increase by 4.8% in 2024. While this is a positive sign, it represents a small recovery from the 5.7% decrease seen in 2023. Builders are likely responding to improved economic conditions and a slight increase in demand.

2025 Housing Starts

In 2025, housing starts are projected to decrease by 4%. This suggests that home builders are not overly optimistic about a sustained recovery in the housing market. The cautious approach reflects the ongoing challenges in affordability and demand.

Long-Term Trends

Overall, the forecast indicates that home builders are not expecting a significant boom in new home construction. The modest changes in housing starts suggest a market that is stabilizing but not experiencing rapid growth.

Forecast for Home Prices and Rates

Fannie Mae's forecast for home prices and mortgage rates provides insights into the future direction of the housing market. While home prices are expected to continue rising, the rate of increase is projected to slow.

Home Price Forecast

Home prices are expected to increase by 6.1% in 2024, followed by a smaller gain of 3% in 2025. This indicates a deceleration in price growth, which could help improve affordability and support higher sales numbers.

Mortgage Rate Forecast

Mortgage rates are projected to decrease gradually over the next two years. By the end of 2025, rates are expected to be around 5.7%, down from 6.2% at the end of 2023. Lower mortgage rates could make homeownership more accessible and encourage more buyers to enter the market.

Implications for the Housing Market

The combination of slower home price growth and lower mortgage rates could help stabilize the housing market. Improved affordability may lead to increased demand, supporting higher sales numbers in the coming years.

Conclusion and Call to Action

Fannie Mae's forecast paints a complex picture of the U.S. housing market, with challenges and opportunities ahead. While home sales are expected to remain low in the near term, there are signs of potential recovery in 2025.

Key Takeaways

  • Home sales are projected to reach a near 30-year low in 2024, with a modest recovery expected in 2025.
  • Economic implications of low home sales include potential impacts on GDP, employment, and consumer spending.
  • Pending home sales and mortgage applications indicate continued challenges in the market.
  • Housing inventory trends show regional variations and the impact of new home construction.
  • Home builders are taking a cautious approach, with modest changes in housing starts projected for the next two years.
  • Home prices are expected to rise at a slower rate, and mortgage rates are projected to decrease gradually.

Posted by

Related Articles: